Appeals Committee: Michael Wilkinson (chairman) , Nye Griffiths, Bruce Neill Board 21 NS Vul Dealer North WEST NORTH   K2   J32   Q1074   A1084 EAST   QJ764   A109   A95   J5 SOUTH   A105   K764   KJ63   72   983   Q85   82   KQ963 Auction and Explanations West North East South P P P 1S P 3H1 P 3S2 P 4S P  P P P P 1 3 card limit raise 2 agreed break in tempo Play - N/A Result:       4SS EW -450 Tournament Directors Statement of Facts and Ruling :    Ruled that Pass was a logical alternative and that 4S may have been suggested by the break in tempo. Score adjusted to NS -200  Decision of the Appeals Committee:     Director's Decision upheld. While East may have acted the same withouth the tempo break, once there had been one we feel pass is a logical alternative. Back to Appeals | Home